How the Mainspring Works: Where a Watch Keeps Its Energy, and Why 42 Hours

Petter Trobe

Somewhere near the edge of every mechanical movement is a small, closed drum with fine teeth around its rim. It looks inert. Inside it is a ribbon of steel alloy, twenty to thirty centimetres long and thinner than a fingernail, coiled tight and pushing outward with a force that, over the next two days, will drive every other part of the watch. This is the mainspring, and it is the only source of energy a mechanical watch has. This is the fourth article in our How It Works series.

The barrel and what is in it

The drum is the barrel. The spring inside is anchored at its inner end to a central shaft, the barrel arbor, and at its outer end to the barrel wall. When you wind the watch, you turn the arbor and coil the spring tighter around it. When you let go, the spring tries to uncoil, and because the arbor is now held by a ratchet, the only thing that can move is the barrel itself. The barrel turns, its teeth drive the first wheel of the gear train, and the train carries the energy onwards to the escapement, which lets it out one tooth at a time.

That is the whole principle. A wound spring is stored work; the gear train and escapement are the means of spending it slowly.

Why old springs broke

For roughly four and a half centuries mainsprings were made of hardened carbon steel, and they were the most unreliable part of the watch. They broke, often when almost fully wound, with a snap you could feel through the case. They took a permanent set, losing their curve and storing less energy as they aged. And they rusted; carbon steel is extremely sensitive to moisture, and a trace of surface rust was enough to start a crack. One American manufacturer found, just after the Second World War, that nearly a third of its warranty returns were mainspring failures.

The solution came from metallurgy. In the 1940s Elgin in the United States developed a cobalt-based alloy spring, and in Switzerland Reinhard Straumann's company introduced Nivaflex, an alloy of cobalt, nickel, chromium and iron with small amounts of tungsten, molybdenum, titanium and beryllium. These springs do not rust, do not set, are essentially non-magnetic and almost never break. By the early 1960s carbon-steel mainspring production had ceased. The spring in a Miyota 82S0 is of this modern kind, which is one reason a movement built for a few tens of dollars can run for decades.

The problem that never quite goes away

A spring does not push evenly. Fully wound, it delivers a great deal of torque; as it unwinds, the torque falls. The balance wheel, which is the timekeeper, swings in a wider arc when it receives more energy and a narrower one when it receives less, and although a good balance and hairspring are designed to take the same time per swing regardless of arc, no real oscillator manages this perfectly. Watchmakers call the ideal isochronism, and the failure to achieve it is why a watch's rate changes slightly as it runs down. Some loss of accuracy near the end of the power reserve is, as one writer puts it, unavoidable.

Horology's first great answer, from the fifteenth century, was the fusee: a cone-shaped pulley connected to the barrel by a fine chain, so that when the spring was strong it pulled on the narrow end of the cone and when weak on the wide end, evening out the torque. It was ingenious and it was standard in English watches until about 1900. But it was bulky, and once mainsprings became long enough that only the flattest part of their torque curve was used, the Swiss and American industries abandoned it for the simpler going barrel, which is what every modern watch uses. The fusee survives today as a showpiece complication in a handful of very expensive watches.

Power reserve: why about forty hours

A watch's power reserve is how long it runs from full wind to stop. Most automatic movements are designed for somewhere between 36 and 48 hours; the Miyota 82S0 quotes approximately 42. The number is not arbitrary. It is one day on the wrist, one night on the nightstand, and a margin for a lazy morning. If you wear the watch daily, the rotor keeps the spring near full and you never see the bottom of the reserve, which is exactly where you do not want to be.

Longer reserves have become a selling point, and it is worth knowing how they are achieved, because it is never by magic. The Tissot Powermatic 80, built on the ETA 2824 architecture, gets eighty hours partly from a more efficient barrel and partly by slowing the beat from 28,800 to 21,600 vibrations per hour, so that each swing costs less. Rolex's calibre 3235 reaches seventy hours by machining the barrel walls to half their old thickness to fit a longer, thinner spring, and by fitting a more efficient escapement that wastes less energy on every tick. A long reserve is a set of engineering trade-offs, and a movement that runs for eighty hours is not necessarily more accurate across those hours than one that runs for forty.

The spring you cannot overwind

In a hand-wound watch the outer end of the mainspring is hooked firmly to the barrel wall, and when the spring is fully coiled the crown simply stops. Automatic movements cannot work that way, because the rotor would keep winding an already-full spring. Instead their springs end in a short, curved bridle that holds the barrel wall by friction alone. Wind past full and the bridle slips a fraction of a turn. This is why you can wind an 82S0 by hand as much as you like without harm, and why the old warning about overwinding belongs to manual watches only.

What this means at the bench

In the Calibre Learning Kit you will not open the barrel; a mainspring under tension is one of the few parts of a movement that can actually hurt you, and fitting one properly needs a winder. But you will handle the barrel as a unit, and you will learn the two rules that go with it. First, let the power down before you take a movement apart. Release the click while holding the crown, let the spring unwind gently, and only then remove the balance and the train. Taking a bridge off a fully wound train can send the wheels spinning with enough force to bend a pivot. Second, when the movement is reassembled and will not run, ask whether it has any power to run with. A surprising number of dead watches are simply unwound.

Give the crown a dozen turns, watch the balance start, and think of the ribbon in the drum, quietly spending itself.

Common misunderstandings

You cannot overwind a modern automatic; the bridle slips. A longer power reserve does not mean a better or more accurate watch; it means a different set of compromises. Modern mainsprings do not break routinely, though a very old watch may still have a carbon-steel spring that does. And the mainspring is not the timekeeper; it is the fuel tank.

Sources and further reading

Tilbake til bloggen