John Harrison and the Longitude Problem: The Carpenter Who Built the Clock That Found the Sea
Petter TrobeShare
On the night of 22 October 1707, a British fleet returning from the Mediterranean ran onto the rocks of the Isles of Scilly. Four ships sank and more than 1,400 men drowned, among them the fleet's commander, Sir Cloudesley Shovell. The navigators had believed they were safely west of the islands. They were not, because nobody at sea in 1707 could measure how far east or west they were.
Latitude was easy: you measure the height of the sun or the pole star. Longitude is a question of time. The Earth turns fifteen degrees an hour, so if you know the time at a reference point, say Greenwich, and you know your local time from the sun, the difference is your longitude. The problem was the first half. No clock in 1707 could keep time on a pitching, rolling, damp, hot-and-cold ship for weeks on end. This is the story of the man who built one.
Twenty thousand pounds
The Longitude Act received royal assent on 9 July 1714. It offered rewards of up to 20,000 pounds, which the Royal Museums Greenwich reckons at well over a million and a half pounds today, to anyone who could find longitude at sea to within half a degree. A Board of Longitude, made up of astronomers, admirals and mathematicians, would judge the claims. Most of them expected the answer to come from astronomy, from tables of the moon's motion. Almost nobody expected it from a clock.
The carpenter from Foulby
John Harrison was born in March 1693 in Foulby, Yorkshire, the son of a carpenter, and became a carpenter himself. He had no formal training in clockmaking. He taught himself, built his first clocks largely from wood, and by the early 1720s, working on a pair of tower clocks for Brocklesby Park, had already invented two things that would follow him through his life. The gridiron pendulum used rods of brass and steel, which expand at different rates, so that the pendulum's length stayed constant as the temperature changed. The grasshopper escapement, with its two pivoting arms that kick the escape wheel with almost no sliding contact, needed no oil at all. Oil, in the eighteenth century, was the enemy: it thickened in cold, thinned in heat and went rancid at sea.
H1: the first clock that went to sea
Harrison went to London in 1730 with drawings, won a small grant, and spent five years building his first marine timekeeper. H1, completed in 1735, is a strange and beautiful thing, a brass frame of about 62 by 68 centimetres with four dials and two large dumbbell-shaped balances linked by springs, so that the rolling of a ship would disturb one exactly as much as the other and cancel out. It used his gridiron temperature compensation and it ran without lubrication.
In 1736 H1 sailed to Lisbon and back aboard HMS Centurion. On the return leg the ship's master announced they were approaching Start Point in Devon. Harrison, consulting his clock, said they were sixty miles further west, off the Lizard in Cornwall. Harrison was right. The Board of Longitude gave him 500 pounds to continue, and the museum in Greenwich now describes H1 as the first relatively successful marine timekeeper of any kind.
H2, H3 and nineteen years
H2, built between 1737 and 1739, was bigger and heavier and included a remontoire, a small secondary spring that isolated the escapement from the mainspring's uneven pull. Harrison then found a flaw in the way its balances responded to the ship's turning and refused to let it go to sea. He started again.
H3 took him nearly nineteen years, from 1740 to 1759, and although it never satisfied him, it produced two inventions that outlived the clock. The bimetallic strip, two metals bonded together that curl as the temperature changes, is still in thermostats today. The caged roller bearing, a set of rollers held in a frame to reduce friction, is in almost every machine with a rotating shaft. Harrison invented both while trying to make a clock go straight on a ship.
H4: the watch
Then, at the age of sixty-two, he changed his mind about the whole approach. In 1753 a London watchmaker named John Jefferys had made a pocket watch to Harrison's design, and it kept time far better than a pocket watch had any right to. Harrison realised that a fast-beating, well-made watch, small enough to be insulated from the ship's motion, might do what three large clocks could not. He began H4 in 1755 and finished it in 1759. It is thirteen centimetres across, weighs one and a half kilograms, and looks like an enormous, exquisite pocket watch.
In 1761 H4 sailed to Jamaica aboard HMS Deptford in the care of Harrison's son William. On arrival, after 81 days, it was found to be about five seconds slow, which corresponds to roughly a mile and a quarter of longitude, well inside the half-degree the Act demanded. A second trial to Barbados in 1764 gave an error of 39 seconds, still comfortably within the limit.
The Board, the Astronomer Royal and the King
What followed is the reason Harrison's story is still told with some anger. The Board, chaired from 1765 by the Astronomer Royal Nevil Maskelyne, who was himself a champion of the rival lunar-distance method, paid Harrison 10,000 pounds but demanded that he explain the watch's construction in full, hand it over, and demonstrate that copies could be made. In 1766 Maskelyne collected H4 and Harrison's other timekeepers, sealed in a box, and took them to Greenwich for further trials that Harrison regarded as rigged.
Harrison, by now in his seventies, built one more watch, H5, and in 1772 persuaded King George III to test it personally at his private observatory at Richmond. It kept time to within a third of a second a day. With the King's support, Harrison petitioned Parliament directly, and in 1773 it voted him 8,750 pounds. He was eighty years old. He never received the prize as such; the Board of Longitude never formally awarded it to anyone. He died in London on 24 March 1776, on his eighty-third birthday.
The copy that sailed with Cook
The Board did commission a copy. Larcum Kendall, a London watchmaker, was paid 450 pounds to reproduce H4 and delivered K1 in 1769. It sailed with Captain James Cook on his second and third voyages, across the Pacific and into the Antarctic, and Cook's journals call it our trusty friend the watch and our never-failing guide. It was K1, more than any trial, that convinced the Navy. Within a generation the marine chronometer was standard equipment, and the word chronometer still means a watch that has been tested and certified to keep time.
Why this matters to someone learning watchmaking
Harrison was a self-taught outsider who spent forty years on a problem the experts had assigned to astronomy. His first clocks were made of wood because that is what he knew. He got three of them wrong, by his own standards, before he found the answer in something smaller than he had imagined. Almost every technique he invented along the way was a way of managing friction, temperature and lubrication, which are the same three problems a watchmaker manages today when regulating a movement.
H1, H2, H3, H4 and K1 are all on display at the Royal Observatory in Greenwich, and H1, H2 and H3 are kept running. If you are ever in London, go. It is one of the few places where you can watch the eighteenth century keep time. And the next time you set the balance into a Miyota 82S0 and watch it swing, you can think of the carpenter who first worked out how to make such a thing behave at sea.
Sources and further reading
- Royal Museums Greenwich, Longitude found: John Harrison
- Royal Museums Greenwich, What made the search for longitude so important?
- Royal Museums Greenwich, collection records for H1, H2, H3, H4 and K1
- Royal Observatory Greenwich, John Harrison's marine timekeepers
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, John Harrison
- Wikipedia, John Harrison
- Dava Sobel, Longitude (1995), the popular account of the story